I would say that these qualities are expected in most leaders, past and present. Would you agree? Beowulf is described as a good leader. He seems to be fair and just from what we are given and he doesn’t show any blatant cruelty. The way he jumps into situations shows that he can adapt to different situations and that he is very confident in himself and he displays a kind of intelligence. He shows his honor when he tries to make his fights fair.
Empathy, bravery, and self awareness seem to be harder to see in Beowulf. Though he is fair, he doesn’t seem to be empathetic. I see this mostly when he faces Grendal as well as when he marches out to fight the dragon. Beowulf seems to be constructed to be the poster child of bravery but is he
actually brave? He doesn't overcome anything. He doesn’t seem to be afraid at all. So is he really brave? Self awareness seems to be the one that ends up being his downfall. He can not see how much his own pride is affecting him, especially when it is the cause of his death when he goes up against the dragon.
Can Beowulf really be seen as a “good leader” despite his flaws?
I think something has gone amiss with your images ... you can edit your post and fix this. Be sure you insert them using the picture button rather than copying and pasting them into your post!
ReplyDeleteI think the one thing Beowulf overcomes is his own life. (If that makes sense.) We first see him as a young man emerge and conquer Grendel, and lastly see him as an older man conquer the dragon.
ReplyDeleteThe fact that he dies during this battle is interesting...could it be an allusion to the limitations that old age brings? Maybe?
Anyway...even if Beowulf doesn't have any mental challenges we see, we do witness him grow up from a young man to an older leader. Perhaps that's a journey, a challenge we witness Beowulf overcome himself? After all, a life as full as his can't be easy to live.
All in all, I do like Beowulf. I recognize his arrogance, but it makes me crack a smile if anything.
You mentioned Beowulf's lack of self awareness as an enormous flaw that lead to his down fall and I am inclined to agree with this. His lack of foresight and general absorption are his tragic flaws.I think he is a poor leader because he is not leading anyone.
ReplyDelete